• Books
  • Film
  • Media
    • Daily News Egypt
  • Music
  • Politics
  • Religion
  • Sirgo’s
  • Social
  • Sport
  • Travel
  • Uncategorized
  • Writing
  • By Me
  • About

Sirgo’s Labyrinth

~ On Egypt news & other things on my mind

Sirgo’s Labyrinth

Tag Archives: paintings

Sexuality, Eroticism & Obscenity

13 Sunday Dec 2009

Posted by Ssirgany in Uncategorized

≈ 5 Comments

Tags

audience, Books, censorship, cinema, conservative, critics, culture, Daily News Egypt, drawing, Egypt, Film, filmmaker, foul, Ghada Amer, liberal, literary scene, literature, novels, paintings, respect, sarah el sirgany, sensual, sex and art, sexy, sirgany, viewers

For some, these three words are synonymous, for others they couldn’t be more different. Is it the culture that dictates the difference/similarity? Is it the subject at hand? Are the lines generally blurred?

We recently had this discussion at Daily News Egypt, prior to publishing this story: Guns, wars and chadors: the art of Ghada Amer.

Our culture editor Joseph Fahim sent me the two pictures that ran with this story with a note to check them first and tell him if they are fit for print. He said he didn’t see anything wrong with them, but wanted us to give them a closer look.

I looked, I couldn’t find anything unprintable. If you go to the article and scroll down, you’ll find that in the second picture, the multi layered drawing explores the female form, but the sexual connotation might be lost on anyone who doesn’t give it a closer look. But google “Ghada Amer” and you’ll see more of her in-your-face work available online.

She probes the female form, explores its sexuality, and challenges any form of (self) censorship.

But how would you describe her work? Sexual? Erotic? Obscene?

During the discussion, DNE Editor Rania Al-Malky correctly pointed out that ‘erotic’ is a description, while ‘obscene’ is a judgment, citing literary debates. But in our culture, would such distinction hold?

Many see sexual as erotic and in turn consider both obscene. And it’s not just the conservatism in our culture. Traces of similar attitudes can be seen — to a much lesser degree — in literary venues in more liberal societies. Even though writers like the respected and established novelist and essayist Zadie Smith have written or edited erotic stories (she edited a an anthology of erotic short stories according to her Wikipedia page), many literary journals and consumer magazines in the US and the UK that publish short stories, poems and novel excerpts have the “we don’t accept erotica” label on their publishing guidelines. The genre is often dismissed as lower or cheaper form of literature, even though the word “erotica”  implies art as opposed to mere pornography.

Yet “sexual” scenes in literature are not dismissed or considered demeaning of any good piece of literature. Many classics and reputable contemporary bestsellers freely describe heterosexual and homosexual encounters without fear of denigration.

This distinction between sex-centered work and work that happens to include sex is for the most part non-existent here. Take Ehsan Abdel-Quodous for example. His work, famous for its critique of societal hypocrisies and women-centered narratives, was labeled as “Adab El Ferash” back in the 60s. It literally means “the literature of the mattresses” and was used as a derogatory term in reference to more intimate scenes in his short stories and novels.

Back then the existence of lines between sexuality, eroticism and obscenity was not even acknowledged. Forward 40 years, and the situation isn’t that different. When Alaa El-Aswany first released his sophomore novel “Chicago” in a series in El-Dostor, the tone of readers’ letters got a bit more aggressive as two of the protagonists’ relationship turned physical. The novel as a whole got the criticism of “too much sex”. Needless to say, the phrase itself is used as an insult, implying that the author is using sex to sell his literature.

But in a panel discussion following the release of the novel, Economist Galal Amin came to the rescue. He argued that sex scenes should be viewed through the eyes of the characters involved. If a man sees his daughter having sex, then the emotion shouldn’t be eroticism but the man’s own shock.

Basically, Amin argued for desexualizing the sex scenes, to remove the sexuality, eroticism, and definitely the obscenity that are always associated with similar literary depictions.

Would such endeavor find a lot of welcoming ears here in Egypt?

While it’s more probable to happen in the literary world, other more visual arts might not be as welcoming. I can’t see that the public and the critics would dissociate a local film, for example, from its more intimate scenes. Films that sell through a promise of steamy scenes would be bundled with others of better caliber that happen to include or allude to sex.

And with Ghada Amer’s work, she said she’s not expecting it to be displayed in Egypt any time soon. I’m not holding my breath either.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
  • More
  • Reddit
  • Print

Like this:

Like Loading...

مذكرات التحرير

BUY I Diari Della Rivoluzione

Top Posts

  • The addictive cycle of TV news
  • عن الفقدان والأمل
  • Jumbled memories of loss and hope
  • Realizing death
  • هو أنا بقيت بأشتم ليه
  • Five months in news

Pages

  • About
  • By Me

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 89,169 other followers

RSS Feed RSS - Posts

RSS Feed RSS - Comments

Recent Comments

steel panther tour on Kahk: It’s not about eating; i…
kshihabi on عن الفقدان والأمل
car rims on Sexuality, Eroticism &…
cleaning chrome rims on Spinning the flotilla story as…
إبراهيم علي on هو أنا بقيت بأشتم ليه

On Twitter/Ssirgany

  • RT @LinaAlhathloul: Public prosecutor and Loujain can still appeal. 2 weeks ago
  • RT @LinaAlhathloul: BREAKING : Today @LoujainHathloul was sentenced to -5 years and 8 months in prison - A suspension of 2 years and 10 mo… 2 weeks ago
  • RT @tamaraqiblawi: Health Minister announces new covid strain is here in Lebanon — arrived on a London flight on Dec 21. Daily tally has su… 3 weeks ago
  • RT @hossambahgat: Part of my interview with @camanpour together with @Jeky_Kelly on the campaign to #freeEIPRstaff twitter.com/camanpour/stat… 1 month ago
  • RT @stephenfry: A good person very wrongly imprisoned. Find out more here – FreeKarim.com #FreeKarimEnnarah #FreeEIPRstaff @EIP… 1 month ago
  • Gasser has refrained from being a public figure, and might find this article too divulging, but he would perhaps to… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 1 month ago
  • EIPR director Gasser Abdel Razek told lawyers today he was in solitary confinement, his head was shaved, his belong… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 1 month ago
  • RT @ExtSpoxEU: Egypt: EU conveyed to Cairo significant concerns about arrests of members of @EIPR who provides important services to 🇪🇬peop… 1 month ago
  • RT @hackneylad: Karim Ennarah - a ferociously smart researcher and advocate for the basic rights and freedoms of his fellow citizens - is t… 1 month ago
  • RT @ACLU: Because President Trump has cozied up to strongmen leaders across the globe, the Egyptian government believes it can jail the cou… 1 month ago
  • RT @hossambahgat: Today I go back to leading @EIPR till the release of its leaders. Founding #EIPR in 2002 and managing it for 10 years is… 1 month ago
  • RT @MadaMasr: Security forces arrested Gasser Abdel Razek, the executive director of the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights, from his… 1 month ago
  • RT @katie_polglase: We're still waiting on a response from the Nigerian authorities to our investigation. We have examined hours of footage… 1 month ago
  • Karim is a brilliant researcher doing much needed work under stifling restrictions on human rights defenders, lawye… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 1 month ago
  • RT @SimonaFoltyn: When you're recording a segment about the planned US troop drawdown in #Iraq and a rocket, followed by CRAM projectiles,… 1 month ago
  • RT @ayaelb: Drugs for diabetes and blood pressure, anti-depressants and fever pills used in COVID-19 treatment have disappeared from shelve… 2 months ago
  • RT @jmhansler: NEW: @SecPompeo announced Tuesday that the US had formally notified Congress of its intent to sell approximately $23 billion… 2 months ago
  • The Husband-and-Wife Team Behind the Leading Vaccine to Solve Covid-19 nyti.ms/32wbPVS 2 months ago
  • RT @munaluqman: Jannat is a smart young girl from #Taiz #Yemen studying & supporting her family I had a video call with her we surprised… 2 months ago
  • السعودية الوحيدة خليجيا لم تهنئ بايدن بالفوز وسط تساؤلات مغردين arabic.cnn.com/middle-east/ar… via @cnnarabic 2 months ago

Flickr Photos

S OP Anti SH_1487F OP Anti SH_1510S OP Anti SH_1469F OP Anti SH_1508F OP Anti SH_1457F OP Anti SH_1450F OP Anti SH_1451F OP Anti SH_1415F OP Anti SH_1409F OP Anti SH_1382
More Photos

Blogroll

  • 3arabawy
  • Al Khan
  • Backpacking to Babylon
  • bigHead
  • Cairo Freeze!
  • Chatoyant Crumbs
  • CHLOÉ & CLEO
  • Egyptian Chronicles
  • Inanities
  • Kirmalak
  • Ma3t
  • Manal and Alaa's bit bucket
  • Moftasa.net
  • Nadia El-Awady
  • Paging Mr Driftwood
  • Poetechnique
  • Rantings of a Sandmonkey
  • Sibilant Egypt
  • The Arabist
  • The Boursa Exchange
  • The Traveller Within
  • لستُ أدرى
  • وَيلك دوت نت
  • أسد
  • جبهة التهييس الشعبية

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.com

Pages

  • About
  • By Me

Blog at WordPress.com.

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
%d bloggers like this: